Fortunately, Founders' distribution channels grew in 2017 and now distributes to the PNW. After having both Founders Porter and Black Butte Porter, separately, I always wondered if they were the same beer because they tasted so dang close to each other. Are they basically the same? Drastically different? There was only one way to find out!
Founders Porter | Black Butte | |
Appearance | Darker. Zero transparency; not as much foamy head, and not as much head retention | Dark, but a Bit lighter. Some slight transparency; larger foamy head; LONG head retention |
Aroma | More caramel/toffee; red fruit | more roast; pear |
Mouthfeel | thicker mouthfeel; not as carbonated | thick mouthfeel, but thinner than founders; sharp carbonation |
Flavor | more bitter; lower notes of caramel/toffee | bit more sweetness; higher notes |
Overall | a bit heavier, more toasty roasty and lower note flavors | a bit lighter, higher notes |
Both beers are fantastic porters to drink. If you want a porter that has a bit more of an edge to it and some more roast, pick the Founders. If you want a bit smoother and slightly lighter (not much! but enough to notice!), pick the Black Butte Porter from Deschutes.
Both go well with shucked salted peanuts :)